Costco's reputation for low prices doesn't apply to everything on its shelves.

Milk costs less at Walmart and Aldi, which use it as a loss leader to draw customers. Brand-name breakfast cereals at Costco carry higher price points than private-label options at Walmart and Aldi. Boneless and skinless chicken breasts are cheaper elsewhere, despite Costco's known deals on rotisserie chicken. Books have become a weaker value since Costco scaled back its book aisles, with Amazon often offering better variety and pricing. The exception is curated multi-book children's sets, which Costco prioritizes.

Avocados present a bulk-buying problem. Costco sells them only in bags of five to six, while Aldi, Trader Joe's, and Walmart let you buy individual avocados. Buying in bulk makes sense only if you'll use them before they expire.

Bulk food in general can backfire. Bakery items, salad greens, and fresh produce spoil quickly. A 20-to-25-pound bag of baking flour takes significant storage space and may expire before use. Other grocers offer smaller sizes.

Discounted gift cards at Costco can lead to overspending. A $100 restaurant gift card sold for $80 becomes a poor deal if you then spend $150 dining there, raising your total cost above your original budget. These cards work best when limited to retailers you already frequent.