Pet insurance premiums rise sharply as pets age and vary significantly by breed. Enrolling a young pet locks in lower rates, while high-risk dog breeds cost 50% to 75% more than low-risk breeds, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).
Dog owners pay about $836 per year on average for accident and illness coverage, while cat owners pay $435 per year, according to the North American Pet Health Insurance Association. Mixed-breed dogs are cheaper to insure than purebreds because they face lower risk of breed-specific conditions. French bulldogs tend to be the priciest dogs to insure.
Cats show less price variation between breeds than dogs. Higher-risk cat breeds cost 0% to 50% more than low-risk ones. However, a 10-year-old cat can cost about five times as much to insure as a one-year-old.
Certain breeds face elevated health risks. Golden retrievers, Bernese mountain dogs and rottweilers are more likely to develop cancer. Great Danes, German shepherds and Saint Bernards have higher risk of hip dysplasia. Pugs, boxers and bulldogs are prone to breathing issues. Persians face risk of polycystic kidney disease, while Maine coons and Ragdolls are more likely to develop heart conditions.
Chronic conditions drive up costs. About a quarter of pet owners with chronically ill pets spent $5,000 to $10,000 in the past year, according to a 2026 Money and Healthy Paws Pet Insurance survey.
To lower premiums, enroll your pet young. Switching insurers as your pet ages may backfire, since new insurers typically treat existing conditions as pre-existing and exclude them. Raising your deductible or lowering your reimbursement percentage also reduces monthly payments. Routine vet visits and preventative care can help avoid costlier health issues later.