Congress has six years to prevent cuts to Social Security retirement benefits. The trust fund used to pay those benefits may start depleting in 2032, when only 78% of scheduled benefits would be payable. If the program's retirement and disability trust funds are combined, depletion would move to 2034, when 83% of benefits would be payable.
Two competing tax proposals dominated midterm campaign debates. Many Democrats and some Republicans called for raising the payroll tax cap, currently set at $184,500 in 2026 and rising to $192,300 in 2027. This would require high earners to pay Social Security taxes on income above that threshold. Some Republican candidates promoted extending a temporary senior tax deduction of up to $6,000 per individual that expires in 2028.
Raising the payroll tax cap has broad public support. A University of Maryland survey fielded in February found 79% of 2,509 adults surveyed support raising taxes for wages over $400,000. This was the most popular reform option tested.
According to Social Security Administration analysis, eliminating the cap entirely starting in 2027 would address 58% of Social Security's long-range funding gap over 75 years. Applying the 12.4% payroll tax to earnings over $250,000 would address 57% of the gap. Applying it to earnings over $400,000 would address 53%.
Sen. Bernie Sanders said on November 7 that his proposal to increase benefits by at least $2,400 per year and "scrap the cap" on Social Security taxes would be a "top priority."
Some experts say Congress may delay tax increases until closer to 2032. Jessica Riedl of the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center said, "In Washington, they love to wait until the last minute." If the cap moved from just under $200,000 to $300,000 annually, someone earning at that higher threshold would pay about $6,700 more in direct payroll taxes.
Republicans may seek benefit cuts like raising the retirement age in exchange for higher taxes, according to Dan Adcock of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare.
The senior tax deduction expires in 2028. Riedl expects lawmakers will likely extend it. "2028 is going to be a presidential election year, and I would not expect either party to be willing to allow any senior tax cuts to expire while they're competing for senior votes," she said.